My comments on You-Tube

My Comments on You-Tube:

Learn Ancient Egyptian Hieroglyphs! Alphabet Part 1

  My Comment: Wrong! Egyptian Hieroglyphs do not represent letters of the English [or Latin] alphabet, nor are they phonograms.

How to read Ancient Egyptian Language

   My comment: Mohamed Ibrahim is wrong: Egyptian hieroglyphs do not equate with letters of the alphabet.

   How The Rosetta Stone Unlocked Hieroglyphics

My comment: Tom Scott is wrong: the Rosetta Stone did not unlocked Hieroglyphics.

Last Judgement of Hunefer, from his tomb

My comment: The explanation of Dr. Beth Harris and Dr. Steven Zucker of this picture of the Hunefer papyrus is not correct.

Secrets of the Egyptian Hieroglyphics

My comment: Nothing in this video said by David Leonardi is correct.

Antonio Brown’s reply: Then what is correct? Thank you.

My reply: See my video on You tube: The Decipherment of Egyptian Hieroglyphs -- Lesson I

My second comment: Nothing said by Adam Alonzi in this video is correct.

Adam Alonzi’s reply: I say "in this presentation historical linguist David Leonardi discusses evidence to support his alternative perspective on hieroglyphic decipherment." This is true. It''s what David does in this video.

  My Reply: You said, “while, Egyptologists have made some progress in the deciphering late Egyptian languages”….
                    There are over 5 thousand different Egyptian hieroglyphs: name one that they have deciphered correctly!
                     You said, Latin influences have led to some phonetic changes [in hieroglyphs]: that is false: hieroglyphs have no phonetic value: it was never a spoken language.
                    Furthermore, what David Leonardi said, you made your own: you supported it. You said, “we” [you are a collaborated, not an independent commentator].

                      Hieroglyphic Writing

          My comment: Egyptian hieroglyphs do not represents letters of the alphabet: ZERO.

            Learn Ancient Egyptian Hieroglyphs!
   Alphabet Part 2

      My comment: Keenan Britt is wrong: Egyptian hieroglyphs do not represent letters of the alphabet.

Egyptian Deities
Daddy Phantom

  A mini-documentary featuring the main Egyptian Deities from Amun to Thoth. Narrated and produced by Daddy Phantom for Solar Core Productions.

             My comment: Not correct!

          Daddy Phantom’s reply: "Not correct!"? That hat on your head isn't "correct" either, but you don't see me f'ing with you on your whacked a YouTube Channel. Don't hate Old Man. Maybe in the next life, you'll make videos this good too. From the looks of things, THAT life is right around the corner.

The Keys of Egypt The Race to Read the    Hieroglyphs

My comment: Hieroglyphs do not represent sounds, letters, or combinations of letters: both Thomas Young and Jean Francois Champollion were wrong.

  assault and battery's reply: You're wrong . They are right.

My reply: See my new video: the Decipherment of Egyptian Hieroglyphs -- Lesson 1 -- on You-tube.

  jeremy toutain's reply: You are a complete loon.

   My Reply: See my new video: the Decipherment of Egyptian Hieroglyphs -- Lesson 2 -- You Tube

Basic Overview of Egyptian
Hieroglyphics

My comment: Most of the information about Egyptian Hieroglyphics on this video is wrong.

The Rosetta Stone of Ancient Egypt Documentary - Our World HD Documentary

          My comment: Thomas Young and Jean Francois Champollion did not decipher Egyptian hieroglyphs: both were wrong. Athanasius Kircher was right.

Egypt's Book of the Dead - Documentary films
My comment: James Wasserman's comments about Ani's Book of the Dead are wrong!

                           Egyptian Symbols
                              DebbieHomewrecker

My comment: This woman is wrong on the meaning of every Egyptian symbol in this video.

Hieroglyphs : Documentary on Hieroglyphs and
   Secrecy (Full Documentary)

     My comment: Thomas Young and Jean-Francois Champollion did not correctly decipher Egyptian Hieroglyphs. Stop the Bull-shit.

            NinetyR Raven 1's reply: You are correct

           My second comment [5/16/17]:
The explanation of the meaning of hieroglyphs in this video by Simon Singh and Dr. Bill Manly are not correct. They are following in the footsteps of Young and Champollion. Both were wrong: Egyptian hieroglyphs have no phonetic or alphabetic value. They are pictorial symbols that explain a divine-genetic-science.

                Top 5 Ancient Egyptian Gods
                              All Top 5

       My comment: the explanation of these 5 Egyptian gods in this video are not correct.

        Top 10 Egyptian Gods and Goddesses
                         WatchMojo.com

          My comment [6/23/17]: The explanation of the top 10 Egyptian Gods and Goddesses by this woman, who ever she is, is not correct. Myths are not historical, they have an allegorical meaning. Egyptian mythology is separate from the meaning of Egyptian hieroglyphs. The meaning of hieroglyphs do not support the myths. Egyptian mythology should be keep separate from the meaning of hieroglyphs: this video fuses the two; therefore, wrong. The background movie images supporting the narration are totally -- fictitious. It may be entertaining; but, it is bogus.

    Decoding the Secrets of Egyptian Hieroglyphs | The Great
       Courses
                Published on Dec 12, 2016

      mY COMMENT: nothing Bob Brier says about the meaning [or decoding] of Egyptian Hieroglyphs is correct: he is wrong about everything. You can't write your name in hieroglyphs, because they don't represent letters or have phonetic value. They are sacred pictorial symbols of a divine science of genetics. This Ph. D is an idiot.

A scene from the Papyrus of Ani at the British Museum's Ancient Egyptian Book of the Dead**

       my comment [6/19/18]: Nothing, that Curator John Taylor says about the meaning of the Papyrus of Ani is correct.

               Illumination: The Egyptian Book of Coming Forth by Day into Light
     Phil Langdon

         my comment:   Phil Landon is not correct.

         Highlighted reply
                 Quantum of Conscience
                  That's good to know but., is Phil Langdon correct?

              My reply: Phil Langdon is wrong: the person holding the hand of Anubis in the Papyrus of Hunefer is not the deceased. It is a person desiring to the know the meaning of hieroglyphs: Anubis, represents super-human perception, his guide.

My second comment: This video is pure fiction: that is not Ani's heart in the scales: the reason in mummification: all internal organs are removed, except the heart; so, you would not think that is Ani's heart in the Scales. It says, ancient Egyptians believed in order to become immortal after death, a spirit must first pass through the underworld: they did not believe this: You made that up: nothing you said is correct. The feather of Maat is not a symbol for truth and justice. What is being weighed: does what you desire--equal to what your body's blood [or egg] is capable of.

           THE EGYPTIAN BOOK OF DEAD(SCROLL OF ANI).mp4
                                                 THE ULTIMATE TRUTH

     My first commeNT:   Stuart Tyson Smith, PhD, and Malcolm Mosher Jr. PHD are wrong: The Book of the Death is not a guide book for the deceased. Dr. Zahi Hawass is also wrong.

        My second comment: Dr. Salima Ikram is also wrong: Egyptians did not mummify their bodies so, that the soul would use them in the afterlife: that is plain crazy.

        My third comment: James Wasserman's description of the weighting of the heart is not correct. It is not Ani's heart.

         mY FOURTH COMMENT: The main narrator of the video, whoever he is, says: to the ancient Egyptians: death was the first step towards salvation: that is false. Prove it. Where--does it say that. That is something, he concocted.

         mY FIFTH COMMENT: This conversation between Ani and his wife, Tutu, in this video is completely fictitious: not true.

         mY sIXTH COMMENT [6/19/18]: The narrator of this video says, the Papyrus of Ani, illustrates a dangerous world, where the dead are terrified by beings: no it doesn't. Those images in the video are fake.

My seventh comment [7/23/18]: James Wasserman says: Ani’s heart will be placed in a scale and balanced against the feather of truth: that is false. The reason in mummification—all organs were removed except the heart; so, you would not think the hieroglyph in the scales was the heart of the deceased. Secondly, the feather of Maat is not a symbol of the truth.

        The Egyptian Book of the Dead: A guidebook for the underworld - Tejal Gala

          my comment:   6/20/18
            The Papyrus of Ani is not a guidebook for dead; therefore, nothing said in this video by Ted-Ed is correct.